Sidney Gambling Machine Raid Highlights Ohio’s Renewed Fight Against ‘Skill Games’

The Ohio Casino Control Commission (OCCC) and the Sidney Police Department seized roughly 40 illegal slot machines and an undisclosed amount of cash as part of an illegal gambling investigation.

Investigators executed a search warrant at The Lucky Spot Skilled Games after receiving complaints that the business was operating gaming machines in violation of state law. The storefront on North Vandemark Drive advertised “skilled games.”

OCCC interim executive director Andromeda Morrison thanked local law enforcement for their help in the matter and remarked that “illegal casinos harm communities and Ohioans that live in them.”

The raid in the Shelby County city of about 20,000 people is the latest action in a fight that Ohio has waged for about 15 years and appears to be flaring up once more.

Keep Reading

Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine Regrets Legalizing Sports Betting in Light of Recent Scandals

Ohio Governor DeWine Says He’ll Continue to Oppose Online Gambling Expansion

New Ohio Bills Signal Trouble for Future iGaming Legalization There

Ohio Skill Games: Familiar Fight With a New Name

Ohio law treats gambling as illegal unless the state has specifically authorized and regulated it. That short list includes four voter-approved casinos, seven racinos at racetracks, the state lottery, charitable bingo, and, since January 2023, licensed sportsbooks. Everything else falls into a gray zone, at best, that some operators have long tried to exploit.

Operators used “internet cafes” as their cover for many years. Customers would buy phone or internet time and get “sweepstakes” entries they could use to play on terminals that looked and behaved very much like slot machines, with winners getting cash payouts. Operators insisted these were legal sweepstakes, similar to giveaways that fast food chains offer.

They now use the new label “skill game” or “skilled games,” arguing that these devices reward player decisions and aren’t pure chance. That’s why they believe these machines fall under Ohio’s narrow carve-out for “skill-based amusement machines.”

The Sidney seizure suggests regulators are once again treating the “skill” branding as a distinction with little legal difference.

Gov. DeWine’s Long History With Gambling Halls

The man now in the governor’s office helped write the playbook for cracking down on these machines. As Ohio’s attorney general in March 2011, Mike DeWine announced a legislative proposal to establish oversight of gaming at establishments such as internet cafes.

He said at the time that, “Internet cafes and sweepstakes that are skirting the law are growing in many of our communities.” He presented regulation as a way to protect consumers, police, and charities.

The OCCC backed the 2011 proposal, which would require any sweepstakes machine or skill-based amusement machine to undergo preplay certification, get a license from the OCCC after lab testing, display the license and an inspection sticker for easy public verification, and face criminal penalties for violations. DeWine argued that without these guardrails, Ohio could quickly become a “Wild, Wild West” of unregulated operators profiting at the expense of residents.

He never fully embraced the licensing model. A 2013 law eventually shut off the internet cafe boom by effectively banning parlors and capping their cash payouts at a token amount. DeWine then created a dedicated internet gaming enforcement unit and taught police and prosecutors how to investigate and charge operators.

While the storefronts thinned out from reported highs of 800, cash-paying, slot-like machines didn’t disappear from strip malls.

A Governor Who Keeps Targeting the Sector

DeWine’s wariness toward gambling hasn’t dulled in his second term as governor, even as Ohio has significantly expanded the legal gambling offerings on his watch.

He has repeatedly leaned on the sports betting industry that launched in Ohio in 2023. Just months after platforms went live, his budget doubled the tax on sportsbook revenue to 20%. He tried to double it again for his 2026-2027 budget plan to 40%, which would have made Ohio one of the heavily taxed betting markets in the country.

DeWine wanted to allocate the extra funds to youth sports and professional sports facilities, including a proposed Cleveland Browns stadium. DeWine argued that it was “only just and fair” to try to get bettors to help foot the bill for Ohioans losing large sums on bets.

His own party’s lawmakers opposed the proposal and removed the increase from the final budget. DeWine has seemed equally wary of expanding iGaming to offer online poker and casino games. DeWine suggested that Ohio “probably” has enough gambling already.

After the high-profile baseball scandal involving Cleveland Guardians pitchers, which is still being litigated, DeWine said he regrets opening the door to online sportsbooks.

What the Sidney Case Shows

The case in Sidney is small. It features just a single business and only about 40 machines, and investigators have not announced charges yet. However, it fits a well-trodden pattern in Ohio.

The OCCC’s message was that the “skill games” label on the door doesn’t decide the legal question and that the regulator is taking firm action as soon as these machines pop up in Ohio after seeing them infiltrate other states.

Skill games have been a divisive issue for years in Pennsylvania. Texas is now grappling with them, and North Carolina is playing whack-a-mole with “fish arcades.”

Andrew O'Malley

Editor

Andrew O’Malley has been involved in the gambling industry for more than a decade. With a background in math and finance, he brings a unique perspective to gambling journalism. He covers everything from the latest prediction market litigation to sports betting scandals and iGaming legislation for publications like Gambling Insider and Gaming America. As a gambling journalist, Andrew closely follows breaking stories while also producing in-depth analysis pieces. He frequently speaks with experts in their respective fields to provide unique and informed perspectives.