The Movie Future Of A Beloved Fantasy Book Adaptation Has Never Looked Less Certain

_

By

Zoe Miskelly

Published Apr 21, 2026, 8:00 AM EDT

Zoë Miskelly is an editor and second in command for Screen Rant's Movies team, having covered the entertainment industry for almost 10 years now. Zoë's love of superheroes and all things Marvel & DC started out in childhood, and has blossomed into a career getting to talk about some of the biggest and best movies and shows of all time, having previously focused on comics while working at WhatCulture.

Sign in to your ScreenRant account

The previously impending movie adaptation of a beloved fantasy book series may have just met an untimely end based on the latest reports about Netflix's production plans for the franchise. Of all the many book genres that have eventually been given a second life on-screen, fantasy is quite possibly the most successful in terms of being taken from the written page to film format, since the epic sprawling worlds and intricate plots fantasy books depict translate wonderfully to the big screen.

That said, the popularity of fantasy series and bringing them to life via movie adaptations has its own challenges, since these worlds and narratives tend to need much in the way of dedicated and sustained effort to do full justice, and generally have fans who will have their own detailed pre-determined idea of what a proper film adaptation would look like.

Though Netflix has had a film adaptation of one major fantasy series in the works for years, the future of this project does now appear to be up in the air, as reports suggest that the planned movie and tie-in series set to come with it may now not be going forward after all, despite the considerable amount of time the animated Netflix movie has been in the works for.

Reports Have Emerged That The Redwall Movie May Be Canceled

Luke the Warrior in Redwall raising a sword and shield

After five years of the Redwall movie being in development for Netflix, reports have emerged that the Redwall film has been quietly canceled (as per Animation Magazine and Broadcast Now) alongside the animated series that was also intended to bring the franchise to the streaming service in a major way.

While there has been no official confirmation that these projects have been canceled, it could make sense for the extended production process to end with the Redwall movie and series being canceled, as more extended and complicated production processes can often lead to this kind of outcome.

Similarly, it's easy to see how the Redwall movie may have presented some challenges that could potentially be resolved by simply canceling the Redwall projects. This is first and most obviously clear through the fact that production began in 2021 and thus during the pandemic - adding an immediate complication to matters from the getgo - but the inherent nature of Redwall's story does also seem to present some potential obstacles for any adaptation.

Why A Redwall Movie Is Hard To Make

One of the main appeals of the Redwall book series is that it's a world and story that has elements that will appeal to children and to adults due to its setting and world-building approach. While Redwall focuses on a universe wherein anthropomorphic animals take on the role of humans - giving it a natural appeal to younger readers - the medieval-esque and grounded fantasy style setting also means the series still has many adult fans too.

As much as this shows why a Redwall movie could have been a stellar idea for Netflix to add to its library - and how a follow-up animated series could have had its own success decades after the original animated show adaptation - it also serves to highlight the challenges around making said film in the first place, since the series has a very specific tone and world that would need to be nailed in order to mimic the appeal of the original, all while avoiding being too similar to the prior 2000 movie as well.

This was no doubt a matter made more complex by the original plans for Patrick McHale - who also created Over The Garden Wall_, which expertly balanced being kid-friendly and still appealing to adults thanks to its art and story - to write the script for the project appearing to fall to the wayside in 2022, with McHale confirming to Inverse in December 2022 that he was no longer attached to the movie.

Altogether, if the Redwall movie is indeed canceled, it does seem there could be plenty of reasons that explain why - be that the extended production process the release has been under, the stagnation it appears it may have fallen into after the 2022 update, or due to a lack of confidence about how to handle the source material itself. That said, there's still also reason to hope that a Redwall movie will eventually come to fruition - be that via Netflix or not - since the world and its lore does seem as though it could create a truly gripping modern animated film if handled carefully.